Blog
Planning a large watercolour painting

What goes into making a large watercolour painting? And how do I decide whether I am going to paint a scene in oil or watercolour?
Most artists have heard from one source or another that watercolour is the hardest medium. I didn't hear that until I was well down the road to being a watercolour painter. Now that I paint in both watercolours and oils, I can understand where that statement comes from. Oils are forgiving. Don't like a brushstroke or a part of the painting? Scrape it out and do it again, hopefully doing a better job of it on the second (or third, or fourth) time.
Meanwhile, watercolours are not correctable beyond immediately blotting out a brushstroke with a tissue. Once a stroke of watercolour is down on the paper and dry, there is no taking it back or hiding it with more paint.
For me the biggest difference is that with watercolours I cannot just jump in and wing it. I have to plan ahead and think carefully about how I am going to make the painting. There are painters who do just jump in there and wing it and I love their work too, but I usually cannot function like that (keep reading to where I made an exception).
Here is how I plan my watercolours. I start with an idea. In this case, I had watched the waves breaking over a series of tidal pools in afternoon light and just loved the way the spray cast a warm glow over everything, coupled with the smooth glassy surfaces of the tidal pools filled with water from the previous wave.
I started with a small study. Something to dip my toes into to see if I like the idea once I have seen it in paint. This study is of only part of the scene I wanted to paint. It was too complicated to try to squeeze all of it into an 8x10" so I just chose the part which most spoke to me: smooth tidal pool, golden spray and some of the water cascading out of the pool.

Mirrored Pools, 8x10", watercolour on panel (Click here for larger view)
I liked this. Time to carry on to the next step. Drawing. Ever so much drawing.
I draw the scene full size on a sheet of regular paper. This lets me work and rework the drawing until I get it right. I can erase to my heart's content. Using an eraser on watercolour paper scars it, the paint sinks into those scars and dries darker there, so I have to make my drawing mistakes before I get near a sheet of watercolour paper.
Once I think I have the drawing right, I trace it onto the precious watercolour paper. But I don't leap into colour. I test my composition by painting it in black and white.
Watch this painting develop:
I put the black and white study on a display easel in the studio and looked at it every time I went by, checking for problems/issues to correct before going on.

Mirrored Pools in Black and White, 24x36" watercolour on paper
I made a minor adjustment to the composition and then transferred my drawing on to a new sheet of paper, this time to be painted in colour.
Then I got cold feet. This is a large complicated scene with a lot of soft watery effect to manage. Could I do it?
I took a detour and drew out another painting I'd been meaning to do for a while. This one also has warm light on seaspray and a pattern of rocks in the foreground. I'd painted a smaller study for this a couple of months ago. (See that one here.) It has the same elements but is also less complex. If I painted it almost as large, it would be a great warmup for the larger one.
This is one case where I jumped right in with no pre-planning other than the aformentioned smaller study. No black and white, a very simple drawing. I just went for it. My biggest concern was that I would get overly fussy and fiddly in the details. I wanted to paint this warm-up piece as freshly as I could. "No fussing. No fiddly-widdlies" I kept reminding myself as I worked.
That mantra appeared to help:

Dance of Light and Water, 21x29", watercolour on panel. (Larger view and availability here.)
This came together as I had wanted it to. There are fresh, flowy shifts of colour in the spray. The incoming wave on the left looks like it is moving and where it has hit the shore and exploded into mist it dissolves our view of the distant rocks on the right- soft and loosely painted. Mission accomplished.
Ok. No more stalling. Back to the painting of the tidal pools. I just had to start and then I'd be committed and it would all flow from there. "No fussing, No fiddly-widdlies."
And that appeared to work.

Light Washes Over the Tidal Pools, 24x36", watercolour on panel. (Closeup view and availability by clicking here.)
Finally, to answer the second question I asked at the outset, (how to decide whether to paint a scene in oil or watercolour? ) I usually let the scene tell me. In this case it was all about the glow of light through the mist, glowing off the water. That just seemed to be more suited to depicting with watercolours. Watercolours are really good for transparent shifts of light and colour. Oils on the other hand let me be very deliberate with the colours I choose. If I don't like a colour, I can scrape it out and put it in again.
About a week after painting the large watercolour, I decided to answer the "What If" of how it would have looked if I had painted this in oil paint.

Mirrored Pools in Oil- study, 12x12", oil on board
Was all that planning and painting of studies worth the effort? It appears so.
Light Washes Over the Tidal Pools was awarded Best Watercolour in the February 2021 Plein Air Salon

If you like what you read here, please feel welcome to sign up for my email newsletter . You will get images of my recent paintings and my thoughts about them conveniently delivered right to your email inbox.
18 Responses to Planning a large watercolour painting
Leave a Comment